Blog
Navigating Compliance in the Grey
How Compliance Professionals Can Lead Through Uncertainty
In a perfect world, every compliance question would have a clear, black-and-white answer. But in reality? Compliance professionals often operate in shades of grey.
Whether it’s interpreting evolving regulations, weighing reputational risk, or advising on fast-moving innovation, compliance leaders are frequently called on to guide the business without perfect information — and under pressure.
So how do we stay grounded and provide value in the grey?
1. Anchor in Purpose, Not Perfection
You won’t always have a clear rule to cite — but you can always lead with your organization’s values. When guidance isn’t obvious, ask:
- What decision best reflects our mission and ethical commitments?
- What choice would I feel comfortable defending to a regulator, employee, or the public?
Purpose becomes your compass when rules are fuzzy.
2. Get Comfortable with Calculated Risk
Not all risk is bad. Risk is part of innovation, growth, and strategy.
The goal of compliance isn’t to eliminate all risk — it’s to help the business take the right risks, in an informed and transparent way.
This requires:
- Understanding the business context
- Identifying the “must-nots” and the “coulds”
- Being honest about trade-offs
Empowered compliance leaders don’t just say “no” — they help the business move forward wisely.
3. Embrace the Power of Questions
Sometimes your best tool is a well-timed question. Try:
- “What’s the business objective we’re trying to achieve?”
- “Who could be harmed by this decision?”
- “What’s the reputational or legal impact if this were made public?”
Questions foster reflection, dialogue, and better decisions — even when the answer isn’t obvious.
4. Build a Decision-Making Framework
Having a consistent, principled way to evaluate grey-area choices can reduce stress and improve clarity. Consider:
- What’s legal?
- What’s ethical?
- What’s aligned with our policies?
- What’s in the best interest of stakeholders?
Even if the final decision isn’t perfect, the process can be.
5. Stay Centered Through Community
The weight of uncertainty is lighter when shared. Connect with other compliance professionals. Talk through dilemmas. Normalize the challenge of working in ambiguity.
Ethical leadership isn’t about having all the answers — it’s about showing up with integrity when things are uncertain.
Final Thought
Compliance in the grey isn’t a flaw — it’s where the profession proves its real value. When you guide with clarity, courage, and compassion, you become more than a policy expert. You become a strategic and ethical partner.
Maxine Nogard explores this deeply in The Compliance Advantage — a guide for leaders who know that compliance isn’t just about rules. It’s about wisdom.